
I’ll admit, Netflix’s latest teen flick, Dumplin’, wasn’t a film I went into with very high hopes. With that in mind, I can safely say Dumplin’ surpassed my expectations by quite the stretch. Sometimes it’s great to be wrong – and boy was I wrong. Of course, the film’s no cinematic masterpiece, but it’s not trying to be. Dumplin’ succeeds in all the ways Sierra Burgess Is A Loser failed, sending a positive, heartwarming message about body positivity that doesn’t feel forced or in-your-face politically correct. Dumplin’ has a strong emotional core, with surprisingly realistic characters that balance out the film’s sillier side.
Based on Julia Murphy’s novel of the same name, Dumplin’ follows the story of Willowdean, a teenage girl whose mother, played by Jennifer Aniston, is a former pageant winner. Willowdean always felt more connected to her beloved Aunt Lucy than her image-obsessed mother, as she shared Willowdean’s values of confidence and body positivity – along with a love of Dolly Parton. After the loss of her Aunt Lucy, Willowdean is surprised to discover that Lucy had once wished to enter a pageant like her sister, but never went through with it because of her weight. Willowdean decides to enter her local pageant in honour of her aunt (and in spite of her mother) to prove that you don’t have to be skinny to compete.
I was surprised by how much I liked the main character, Willowdean, played by Australian actress, Danielle Macdonald. Straight off the bat she seemed so have a very strong sense of her identity, which was a refreshing change from the usual strain of self-pity you often see in teenage characters. Yes, Willowdean has issues with her weight, and yes that does affect her confidence, but it certainly doesn’t define her. Unlike Sierra Burgess of Sierra Burgess is a Loser, Willowdean is a charismatic, positive individual that doesn’t make you constantly question why anyone would ever want to spend time with her. This allows the film to explore Willowdean’s struggles with her insecurities in a way that actually feels genuine.
Willowdean’s relationships with her friends and family are similarly genuine, which gives the world of Dumplin’ a wonderfully lived-in energy. Female friendships are the true heart of this film, each one as complex and well-developed as you could hope for given the time constraints. Each female character has their own personal journey and core values. Although they often contradict Willowdean’s, each of them comes to their own throughout the film and are allowed to flourish as their own person. This wide variety of characters, who are each wholeheartedly accepted for who they are (by the end of the film at least) sends a wonderful message to audiences. It was lovely to see such a range of women come together, support one another and most importantly, have a whole lot of fun.
Music plays a large part in the film, and Dolly Parton is the star. Willowdean’s love of Parton is the cherry on top of Dumplin’s southern charm. The music ties the whole film together, from Parton’s greatest hits, to the six original songs she wrote specifically for the film (including the Golden Globe-nominated song, “Girl in the Movies”). The result is an unapologetic celebration of southern style and glamour, through a refreshingly youthful gaze.
The pageant setting just adds to the fun. Similar to Sandra Bullock’s Miss Congeniality (2000), Dumplin’ doesn’t take any definitive stance on pageant culture, merely pointing out some of the positives and negatives along the way and leaving the audience to decide for themselves. Although her mother’s pageant career may have negatively affected Willowdean’s self-esteem, she still gives the pageant a chance. She ends up enjoying her time, whilst remaining thoroughly aware of pageant culture’s faults. Willowdean never had any interest in winning, but she still supports her friend, Millie, who aspires to win the pageant despite her weight. The pageant brought the girls together, and it was just lovely to watch them support each other, regardless of their wildly different priorities. Perhaps in the real world it wouldn’t have been such a fairytale, but it sure does make for a wholesome viewing experience.
The one thing I expected to see a lot more of in Dumplin’ is romance. I was pleasantly surprised to see it take the back seat, as, at no point is romance the main priority of the film. It’s portrayed quite realistically, as one of the many aspects of Willowdean’s life, explored in the form of a charming subplot that, somehow, never feels forced. Willowdean’s love interest, Bo, began the film as her friend and co-worker. You could already see that the two were close – it was just Willowdean’s denial holding their relationship back from progressing further. He had a clear admiration for her from the start, and so it seemed only natural when his feelings took a more definitive turn for the romantic. I enjoyed the depth they brought to the root of Willowdean’s denial, shining light on her hidden insecurities. Despite her confident exterior, Willowdean couldn’t understand why Bo would like her, becoming automatically uncomfortable and self-conscious when he touched her or made any romantic advances. This brought to light how deeply ingrained some prejudices are within us, that no matter how confident you are, social conditioning can still have a huge impact on the way you see yourself. It’s moments like this that are so important to see. It’s such a common thing that often goes unmentioned, and Dumplin’ weaves it in so perfectly.
Is Dumplin’ a perfect film? Not by a longshot, but it’s lighthearted and fun nonetheless, with its fair share of touching, poignant moments along the way. It certainly had far more depth than I expected to see. For fans of teen drama, or coming of age flicks, Dumplin’ is a must watch this holiday season.








